MM-1 Listening Tests and Conclusion

By

In cranking up these speakers we quickly found ourselves flying through both newer and older content to test out the system. Following is a brief summary of our time spent listening to these surprisingly powerful speakers.

CD: Dishwalla - Pet Your Friends
Dishwalla Pet Your Friends"Haze" is the first Dishwalla track we spun up on the MM-1s. I wish I could tell you that there is a specific reason for this, but honestly I just wanted to hear that funky guitar and strolling bass on these little speakers. The guitars have a funky delay that has them originate in the center and then work out to stereo. It's a phenomenal effect and sounded very impressive, though the exact imaging was a bit vague in that the speakers had an almost omnidirectional sense to them. What this meant was that they were interacting with the room a bit more than I was used to, but it wasn't at all unpleasant - just the opposite. The bass, as it slid and walked around during this track simply blew me away. The lower extension of these little drivers was nothing short of amazing and when I actually felt the kick drum, toms, and bass physically impact my chest I couldn't help but look underneath the desk for a small subwoofer. A pair of 3-inch drivers aren't supposed to be able to do this - not while preserving the midrange. B&W has some very capable engineers working in their design department. Seriously, these speakers are way off the traditional path.

The next track was "Give" and it too impressed us with its bassy portrayal of the song's intro. As it went on we noted that the male vocals were clear and sibilance was compression-free. The upper bass frequencies could come across a bit fuller than we'd like, but considering all that these little speakers were pumping out, and the continued clarity of the upper midrange, we found it hard to not be very impressed. The consistent 1/8th note hi-hat during the verse was clear and clean as was the top end of the snappy snare. Distortion was nowhere to be seen. In fact, we found that cranking up this system to its highest levels rendered a transparent, powerful sound. Bowers & Wilkins clearly tested out these speakers to render them able to be played at high volume audible-distortion-free. In general we found that music played at around 90dB or below sounded natural and clean, while anything above that (we were able to coax 97dB peaks without difficulty) tended to boom out and show signs of compression.

CD: Natalie Merchant - Tigerlily
Natalie Merchant TigerlilyThis is such a great album, full of all the things we love about Natalie Merchant. "Wonder" started off our listening for this CD and we loved the simple instrumentation and the upper-mid texture presented by Natalie's edgy voice. The perky guitar sounded great, but the bass was definitely right smack dab in the middle of what we would call the 'mid-bloat' range of the woofers. This is the place where they get a bit muddy overall, though above and below this frequency they do great. You could tell there was just a tad bit of conflict between the tuning frequency of the speakers and the intended sound of the bass guitar. What was nice was that the speakers still presented so much great upper-mid finesse that the song remained very enjoyable overall. We next jumped over to "Carnival" where a mix of percussion and guitar greeted us in a way that made us want to just sit back and enjoy ourselves for a bit. Natalie's vocals cut right overtop of this background rhythm and the choral effect placed on her during the choruses came out sounding beautiful alongside the backing tracks.

CD: Dave Matthews Band - Crash
Dave Matthews CrashThis is such a great album, we just wanted to hear some great music on the B&W MM-1s and Crash seemed to fit the bill. Of course, we started with "Tripping Billies" and sat back while Dave Matthews' vocals poured out liquid delight from the speakers and the varied instruments, including horns and violins, filled the room with a myriad of midrange-heavy material that belied what a normal pair of speakers this size should have any ability to reproduce. What we're used to hearing is breakup distortion at higher volumes when that much is going on - what we got was a symphony of instrumentation that just worked well together.

"So Much to Say" was another song where the kick drum pounded into your chest - which we never really got used to. Now realize, we've heard a much harder punch and greater definition, but these things each had only a three inch woofer! It simply defied logic and we found ourselves backing up the tracks again and again and cranking the volume up, bring people in to hear it... it was that surprising. The snare in this track was awesome and the crisp, woody hits punctuated the midrange while Matthews' vocals poured in around it. Right after this, the guitars in "Two Step" gave us a nice listen to a solidly stereo image and rendered a really nice multitrack effect that spread out and filled in across the entire front of the soundstage. Because of the nature of these nearfields, the soundstage was rather narrow, being limited to the proximity of the speakers. That is to say, they weren't throwing an image wider than themselves, nor was there any mystery as to where the instrumentation was coming from.

CD: Stacy Clark - White Lies
Stacy Clark White LiesWe checked out a newer, more compressed track - Stacy Clark's "White Lies" title track. It is a great song, and the B&W MM-1s seemed to really handle the highly compressed track with no difficulties. In fact, it seemed that the speakers actually thrived with the limited dynamics, as if they were simply blowing off steam and laughed at my meager attempt to trip them up. Stacy's vocals are well into the upper midrange and the tweeters played them back cleanly and without any hint of audible distortion or added compression in the critical sibilance frequencies (~6-8kHz). Cymbal crashes were clean and the overall mix was really well put together and easy to discern throughout the soundstage. Bass was clean and the keys presented themselves with much fanfare behind the overall track, widening the mix and pouring the music into the room.

Conclusion

It's not often that I get to write nearly an entire review while actually evaluating the product I am reviewing non-stop. With the MM-1's that's exactly what I did - and loved every minute of it. Overall, it was obvious that B&W engineers listened to a lot of material when tuning these speakers and found the best possible solution for a majority of music. Female vocals and midrange performance seemed to get the most attention, but man can these things slam on the low end! We've heard a lot of "multimedia" speakers, but the B&W MM-1s have got to be some of the more enjoyable products we've heard. In addition, they offer the absolute best bass performance we've ever experienced from a 2.0 system. They also have the aesthetics to hold up to even the most discerning of consumers - you know the type. So if you plan on docking your iPad between a pair of beautiful speakers, these are probably the ones you should pick up... especially if you loathe the thought of having a large subwoofer anywhere near your desk or workstation. As an added bonus, the brushed aluminum and black will match perfectly and the sound will be just as good, or better, than its looks.

MSRP: $499.95
Bowers & Wilkins
http://www.bowers-wilkins.com

About Bowers & Wilkins
Bowers & Wilkins is Britain’s leading exporter of loudspeakers and the number one imported brand in North America. Since 1966, Bowers & Wilkins’ "Quest for Perfection" has resulted in a succession of technical loudspeaker innovations that have satisfied the world’s most demanding listeners. Its products’ rave reviews and universal acceptance as monitors for professional music recording have helped Bowers & Wilkins become the dominant premium loudspeaker company throughout the world.  To learn more about Zeppelin, Bowers & Wilkins iPod speaker system, and B&W’s home theater and hi-fi models, visit www.bowers-wilkins.com/iPodspeakers.

The Score Card

The scoring below is based on each piece of equipment doing the duty it is designed for. The numbers are weighed heavily with respect to the individual cost of each unit, thus giving a rating roughly equal to:

Performance × Price Factor/Value = Rating

Audioholics.com note: The ratings indicated below are based on subjective listening and objective testing of the product in question. The rating scale is based on performance/value ratio. If you notice better performing products in future reviews that have lower numbers in certain areas, be aware that the value factor is most likely the culprit. Other Audioholics reviewers may rate products solely based on performance, and each reviewer has his/her own system for ratings.

Audioholics Rating Scale

  • StarStarStarStarStar — Excellent
  • StarStarStarStar — Very Good
  • StarStarStar — Good
  • StarStar — Fair
  • Star — Poor
MetricRating
Build QualityStarStarStarStar
AppearanceStarStarStarStarStar
Treble ExtensionStarStarStarStarStar
Treble SmoothnessStarStarStarStar
Midrange AccuracyStarStarStarStarStar
Bass ExtensionStarStarStarStarStar
Bass AccuracyStarStarStar
ImagingStarStarStar
SoundstageStarStar
Dynamic RangeStarStarStarStar
Fit and FinishStarStarStarStarStar
PerformanceStarStarStarStar
ValueStarStarStar
Buy Now
Post Reply
ichigo posts on August 24, 2010 21:27
It looks like it's designed to compete with the Bose MediaMate or some other hyper-small satellite speakers. Based on what I've heard, I don't think these are going to beat larger mid-tier pc speakers in the $200 range.

Notice how there measurements (intentionally) were omitted in the review, although they did measure the Logitech Z-5500s? I'm sure they are horrific and showing them in the review won't go well with B&W's marketing team.

I'm sure it goes well with the Apple Crowd. Spend a lot of money on mid-end products with your favorite company logo and a nice polished skin.
Clint DeBoer posts on August 24, 2010 15:46
ratso;744928
"While the MM-1 speakers feature an audio output if you were to connect any additional speakers or subwoofer the speakers would mute, negating this addition."

so here is another example of a company doing something so amazingly stupid that i'm starting to think it's personal. they just don't like me. why would you put out a bass weak speaker and then NOT allow a sub to be used? just stupid.
Well, in their defense, it's a headphone jack and that is exactly how it SHOULD behave. The Aux jack is an input, not an output, and it operates in tandem with USB.
WaynePflughaupt posts on August 24, 2010 08:48

You can get the Swans M2000 MkII [theaudioinsider.com] and a small sub for less than what the MMI’s cost.

Regards,
Wayne A. Pflughaupt




cwall99 posts on August 23, 2010 13:44
@ratso... I think if you wanted to do that, you should look at the sound card in your computer. I would suspect that a decent sound card, capable of 5.1 audio would have outputs for a subwoofer and three additional speakers.

I think, by design, B&W omitted the surround sound processing circuitry from their speakers.

I'm just guessing, but it seems pretty logical to me.

And it doesn't sound as if they're THAT weak in the bass department, seeing as, on the first page of the review, Clint had these two comments about the pros...

Unbelievable lows
Tactile bass
ratso posts on August 23, 2010 12:20
well here is a product that i have been looking for for quite some time. my wife and kid loves to watch movies and listen to music on the mac. why they don't watch downstairs on the HT i don't know. so i went over to the B+W site to look at this and found this in the FAQ's.

" 17. Can I add additional speakers or a subwoofer to the MM-1 speakers?

While the MM-1 speakers feature an audio output if you were to connect any additional speakers or subwoofer the speakers would mute, negating this addition. "

so here is another example of a company doing something so amazingly stupid that i'm starting to think it's personal. they just don't like me. why would you put out a bass weak speaker and then NOT allow a sub to be used? just stupid.
Post Reply
 
Submit News!