Skip to content. Skip to navigation
You are here: Home Pro Reviews Speakers Floorstanding PSB Alpha Loudspeaker System Review PSB Alpha System Build Quality
 

PSB Alpha System Build Quality

by Ken Stein last modified February 16, 2007 06:53

With such a vast number of speaker manufacturers it is easy to overlook any one of them. I have heard of PSB speakers but never had the opportunity to listen to them nor did I ever pay much attention to their reviews. PSB, which stands for "Paul & Sue Barton", is a company that has been around since the seventies and according to Paul, before that unofficially. Paul, like me, was a Do-It-Yourselfer when he made his first speakers with his father. He took the next step when he started selling speakers to students at a nearby college. He later officially started PSB and did all the designs himself. Not until recent years did Paul petition the help of David Smith to be the company's Director of Product Development because of the large growth that PSB has undergone. The driving philosophy behind PSB is clearly Performance and Value. Their main goal is to offer high performance at reasonable costs and the Alpha Series falls into the entry level "In Room" speaker.

Description and Inspection

The Alpha T1 is a floor standing speaker with an MTM (midrange-tweeter-midrange) configuration. The two 5.25 inch woofers, although they look like metal cones, are made from a polypropylene material. The rubber surrounds are a plus to me because foam surrounds only last about 8 years before they dry rot, and I own speakers older than that that are still in use. The tweeter is a metal dome with a truncated frame which allowed close proximity to the woofers. It has a rear port and the terminal has a 5-way binding post with an extra set of inputs for bi-amping. It has a metal grill which tightly fits inside a frame. The finish is vinyl laminate.

Upon inspection the first thing I noticed were the metal grills. When I received the speakers one of the grills was bent slightly and it never seated right in its frame. They were extremely hard to remove but I'm not sure it was really necessary to remove them. Typically I always like to remove the grills to eliminate any diffraction from the grill itself. In the case of the T1's the grills snapped into a frame, but removing the grills still leaves the frame which is part of the front baffle. All of the drivers were flush-mounted to eliminate diffraction from the driver itself but then there is the edge of the frame for the grill which causes diffraction. The front baffle was made up of two materials; the lower part of the front was MDF and the upper part where the drivers were mounted was molded plastic. Although it seemed rigid, the plastic was not uniform throughout. The rest of the cabinet was made from MDF. Giving it the old knuckle rap test, some parts sounded inert while others did not. Although this cabinet didn't seem to be the most solid design it didn't necessarily need to be. Since the speaker only plays down to 55 Hz they should be set up on your receiver as 舖 Small 舗 speakers and have bass management applied to them. At that setting you are most likely cutting them off at 80 Hz which somewhat reduces the burden for the manufacturer to more amply brace and reinforce the cabinet structure. Keep in mind that this is the PSB entry level speaker. I like to look at it as a bookshelf speaker with a built in stand. That also means that you'd better plan on having a subwoofer or two to go with these T1's.

Taking a look at the inside revealed some interesting things about the design. The woofers were magnetically shielded but the neodymium tweeter was not. I'm not sure if that matters or not but nowadays people are going to digital displays and CRTs will soon be a thing of the past. The 5.25 inch woofer itself was built on a stamped frame which is old technology. Almost all modern drivers are built on a cast aluminum frame for rigidity but many of the budget designs like this still use stamped frames as a cost savings measure. While in the DIY world a stamped frame may be highly frowned upon, it is understandable for budget-minded products like this. Behind the drivers was a bat of 3 ½ inch fiberglass. Speaker design practices say to leave a clear path from the woofer back pressure to the port. This practice wasn't followed since the port is in the rear behind the woofers. There was no absorption material on the side walls or top which would help keep the mid frequencies from reflecting and impinging on the back of the driver cones. The bottom part of the cabinet was completely stuffed with fiberglass with a layer of felt between the upper and lower part of the cabinet. I am not sure the purpose of the felt but it is not acoustically transparent (more like translucent). I think some of that felt should have been used on the side walls for absorption. There was a cross brace behind the tweeter and a shelf brace between the upper and lower parts of the cabinet.

I figured the crossover was somewhere on the bottom near the speaker cup. I didn't think it would be on the speaker cup itself but that's where it was, on the back. I expected something a little bit larger but I am used to seeing a lot more "meat and potatoes" I had to keep reminding myself that these are small budget speakers in a big box, so the design of all components - from box to drivers to the crossover system have to take this in mind in order to get the best bang for the buck possible.

The C1 center channel speaker has the same drivers as the T1 and is essentially the same speaker but in a smaller cabinet. Similarly the B1's are a two way version of the T1 speakers. Both the C1 and the B1 have multiple mounting options. There are a variety of threaded inserts for mounting brackets and two-way keyholes are also provided for hanging the speakers. To my surprise these speakers like the T1s are rear ported. If they are to be hung on the wall or even close to it the rear port gets blocked. I am not sure what the thought process was here but I see this as a design flaw. To circumvent this issue, I recommend stuffing the ports and applying bass management to these speakers when mounting them on or against the wall. The loss of low end extension by doing this wont be realized since you are crossing them over higher than their tuning frequency while at the same time achieving a more uniform sound by reducing boundary gain issues.