| Speaker | Comparison Speaker | Describe the top end of the speaker | Describe the midrange of the speaker | Describe the bass response of the speaker | Describe the soundstage of the speaker | Describe the imaging of the speaker | Describe the dynamic range of the speaker |
| Dali | v Infinity | Lack of high end extension. No air. Rolled off. | Seal's voice recessed into the mix. Bloated midrange with lack of definition; muddy and boxy tonal midrange | Great bass extension on Seal "Crazy"; Slightly muddy lower midrange. | In one track it sounded much narrower than B, but later in "Toy Matinee" it was plenty wide. | Good imaging | Not a lot of dynamic resolution - everything kinda mushed all together |
| Subdued highs; no air, but pleasing | Natural female vocals; when comparing further, the female vocals for Shelby Lynn sounded less natural (tad boxy/artificial) - just that they were so much better than B | Massive bass in Seal - very cool but slightly boomy; solid kick thump in "Happier Girl" (Wellville) | Wide soundstage | Better imaging | Subtleties poked through | ||
| Pleasing hi-hat, crisp | Warm mid, more natural | Tight kick, warm, full bass | wide | More natural, detailed sound, nice placement | Wide range, conveyed full range of dobro, | ||
| v Krix | Clear but sometimes a little too bright | Good presence | Tighter sounding | Larger area | Easy to place sounds | Larger presence with a good natural sound | |
| Muted highs | Smoother mid | Loose, a tad bloated | Wider stage | Vocals spread out – maybe too much | Limited range | ||
| Not real sharp on some of the songs | Slightly reserved sounding in some songs | Lower bass response | Small | Centered focused | Felt like things where held back | ||
| v Salk | Muted highs, no air | Muted female vocals, unnatural; accentuated mid-bass which resulted in muddy overall sound; Everything sounded colored. | Great low frequency response. Tactile effect with Seal's Crazy (vocals more recessed) Thumpier mid-bass (kick). | Cluttered soundstage | Muddy and sloppy imaging | Reduced effect though it certainly goes low and plays loud. Too muddy to show off much. | |
| Flat sounding highs | Warm mid, cupped Shelby’s vocals a bit | Punchy bass, more of a full sound | Narrower stage | Vocals centered (Seal), more distinction in the imaging | Nice bottom, weaker highs | ||
| not always real sharp, but most of the time it was pretty natural sounding | In some of the songs it seemed that the mids got lost in the mix but most of the time it was well balanced | Bass response slightly more reserved | Smaller stage | OK imaging | slightly reserved and almost muffled in some instances | ||
| Infinity | v Krix | More pronounced, unnatural | Boxy, recessed, compressed; Male vocal in Toy Matinee had am radio tonal quality; Lyle Lovett track intro sounded like it was being played over a guitar amp rather than live; way too much mid-bass | Some tactile bass response in Seal track; slightly muddy mid-bass; fuller, but not necessarily accurate-sounding | Very wide and full | Excellent imaging of toms in Toy Matinee track | Felt narrow |
| Bordered on harsh, more of a crispy high | Some cupping on vocal, not as natural | Tighter bass | Tall & narrow | Not as broad, harder to place certain instruments | Unnatural tones | ||
| Clear | Seems like the mids get lost sometimes | Sometimes sounds a little muddled or not as clear | Smaller | OK | Sounds a little more contained | ||
| v Dali | Less defined | Gets lost in the mix sometimes | Bass is a little muddled | Smaller or more focused sounding | not as defined | Seems kind of forced with some music, not as natural | |
| SHRILL | Harsh female vocals, compressed; fatiguing; | Low bass present, not boomy; kick disappears | One-dimensional, probably due to overbearing highs | Some imaging but barely; more or less folds | Narrow | ||
| Not as focused, thin | More tinny mids, completely unnatural male vocal on Toy Matinee | Relaxed bass, boomy on Toy Matinee | narrow | Lousy imaging | Restrained, dobro sounded awful | ||
| v Salk | crisp | Full sounding but with a little extra mid bass in some songs | heavier bass overall but not over the top | Large - wider stage, But on some songs the vocals felt a little off center | Clear overall sound and more warm feeling | More natural sounding but sometimes a little bright on the top end | |
| Good upper mid clarity, but lacking any top-air. | Natural female vocals in "Happier Girl"; Recessed male vocals in Toy Matinee; Rougher female vocals, almost distorted; sounds like it's coming thru a PA system at times (male vocals) | Had slight upper end thump, but no real bass extension for Seal's "Crazy" | Thinner mix; vocals more easily anchored to center; just as placement-finicky as A. A thicker mix. (My guess is both speakers were on the right side of the room since anchoring got better when I moved) | Great imagine on Toy Matinee until the song got more involved, then it got muddy. | Good handling of subtleties and louder content simultaneously (Lyle Lovett tune) but compressed sounding overall | ||
| Relaxed highs | Darker mid. Tone on Shelby vocal not as natural | More of a kick (seal). Nice, punchy bass (Happier Girl) | Wider stage. Stage shifted higher with Toy Matinee. Narrower stage on Shelby & Lyle vocal! | Cleaner sound, but did not image as well. On Lyle Lovett vocal, I felt I could hear the speaker box. | More of a throaty sound | ||
| Krix | v Salk | Reserved highs. Shaker sounds more authentic, tighter | Leaned towards a tinny sound | Fairly tight bass, very warm upper low end on dobro | Wider, more open. Forward staging | Shaker placed more specifically in mix - more centered, focused | Wide range, but not a pleasing speaker for me |
| Bright | Sounds like the mids get a lost between the the high and lows. | Feels like there is more bass, or at least it comes on heavier. | Feels more spread out. | Seems like certain sounds come across as very much in the foreground that should not be and the vocals did not sound center stage. | Sounds like the top end is over emphasized. | ||
| Crisp, but no "air" | Boxy, compressed sounding female vocals in Happier Girl; Forward. Male vocals in later track were recessed | Played only the upper part of the "subsonic" frequencies in Seal track | Dramatically narrower, recessed. Reverb-lade tracks almost collapsed | OK imaging, but when certain tracks came on that were more detailed in their instrumentation, this speaker tended to group everything closer together. | Narrowish bandwidth | ||
| v Infinity | Shaker front and center, natural top end sibilance on Shelby Lynn | More natural male vocals; | Some tactile bass response in Seal track; | Fairly narrow | Narrower soundstage in Toy Matinee, the toms were closer together; | Sounds more dynamic, but partially due to lack of accentuated mid-bass frequencies | |
| More clarity, but relaxed highs | Cleaner mids, warmer | A tad muddy, but still warm | Wide & short | More natural, focused | Nice balanced range | ||
| Clear | Good presence | Realistic | larger | Excellent | Very full sounding | ||
| v Dali | crisper | more mid range definition | heavier bass | large | Feels more spread out | More natural sounding and full sounding | |
| Lots of top end, but brittle and fatiguing. | More pronounced vocals. Female vocals in Wellville's "Happier Girl" were somewhat brittle; Vocals much better than A, but too bright and harsh overall. | Anemic low frequency; | Really wide soundstage | Accurate imaging. Could easily place instruments in the soundstage. | Definitely dynamic - mostly leaning towards availability of high end detail compared to the thumpy mid-bass frequency | ||
| Poor extension of highs, lack of definition | More pronounced mids – too much, too throaty | Sloppy bottom, poor definition, boomy | Narrow, cupped sounding stage | Poor vocal imaging on Seal, overall sound is condensed and feels contained | Range feels limited | ||
| Salk | v Krix | Clear | There is a better presence of the mid range. | Bass seems more balanced with the lows and highs. | Seems like the stage is tighter. | Sounds tighter with the vocals coming from the middle. | Sounds more even across the board without a focus on the highs and lows. |
| Open high end, but not as tight. Exaggerated sibilance on some songs | Natural midrange sound on vocal and guitar solo, warmer mid | Bass a bit loose for my taste, but still full | Stage sounded further back, less aggressive | Shaker placed wider in mix | I don’t feel this speaker has quite the overall impact of A | ||
| More natural highs, less sibilance | More natural male vocals, came into the room | Played "subsonic" frequencies that most speakers don’t reproduce without a sub (more pronounced). Lots more authentic-sounding bass | Wider, more spacious and deep. Vocals stand out more into the room. Reverb-filled tracks poured into the room naturally and pleasingly. | More pinpointed, easier to track specific instruments and vocals | More dynamics | ||
| v Dali | Clean and mostly clear | Showed pretty good definition most of the time | Clear bass | Larger with a wide stage sound | Great imaging | More crisp sounding over all and natural sounding | |
| Brighter highs, a bit crunchy, feels a tad artificial | Upper mids prevail, more open and airy | Thinner bass | Wider stage, bass sits further back in the mix | Weak imaging (Seal & Happier Girl) | Limited range | ||
| Crisp high end, esp on female vocals like Happier Girl | Clean midrange. Superior response and detail to B. Natural sounding female vocals; | Great low frequency response. Tactile effect with Seal's Crazy (vocals more present and up front) | Cleaner soundstage; wide | Solid imaging. Could readily identify exact locations of sounds in Toy Matinee | Articulated dynamic range; subtleties in music poked through while low end and vocals played through | ||
| v Infinity | Crispy shaker in Shelby tune | Less pronounced mid. More pleasing with Shelby vocal. | A bit loose (seal). Less definition (Happier Girl). Bass seems to sit further back | Slighty narrower stage on Happier Girl & Toy Matinee, but widens on Shelby tune. | A bit cluttered at times, but still a decent overall vibe. Sounded more “open” on Lyle Lovett tune. | Less pronounced bottom end | |
| Natural highs, but no high freq. air | Forward male vocals; reverb is lower-mid and more prominent, giving it more "hang-time" and making the mix sound somewhat "fuller". More natural female vocals | Good tactile, clear bass response during Seal's "Crazy" | If you are off-center it quickly pulls in that direction. WIDER. Cleaner | More clearly definable soundstage; remained clear even when more instrumentation kicked in; | Plenty of dynamic range; | ||
| clear | More reserved | Lower bass | Smaller and narrower presentation | More reserved | Slight muffled sound overall |