Skip to content. Skip to navigation
You are here: Home Pro Reviews A/V Receivers Yamaha RX-V2500 Receiver Review RX-V2500 Benchmark Tests - Part 1
 

RX-V2500 Benchmark Tests - Part 1

by Clint DeBoer last modified February 13, 2007 10:51

There has been much discussion on many of the audio forums lately regarding mid priced A/V receivers power capabilities as well as their abilities to drive low impedance loads. Much of the controversy steams around the infamous "All Channels Driven Test" which simulates a best case test load in a worst case environment and by all intents and purposes an unrealistic real world scenario. For more information on this, the reader is encouraged to read our articles on the All Channels Driven Test Controversy and Product Managing Receiver Platforms.

With that, lets all first remember that receivers in the $1k price range from the leading companies today are an absolute bargain regarding their processing power, features, and performance. I like to think of them as an excellent Preamp/Processor (usually rivaling many costlier Pre/Pros) with a free amp thrown in. Whether the amp section within the said receiver is "good enough" depends on the following variables:

  • Loudspeaker Impedance
  • Loudspeaker Efficiency
  • Room Size
  • Room Acoustics
  • Listening Preferences
  • Whether or not you apply bass management to your Loudspeakers and utilize a dedicated powered subwoofer(s).

As you can see, there are a number of variables and the answer is simply not that straight forward. Let's continue on and establish some of the critical test criteria for gauging amplifier performance.

THD and IMD Distortion - This is a measure of how well an amplifier can faithfully reproduce a signal without introducing any artifacts or harmonics. While this is an important metric to consider, most solid state amps these days boast pretty low figures here (usually well below audibility) and are rarely a real world problem for well designed amplifiers.

Signal to Noise Ratio - This is a measurement of importance to consider as it is a ratio of the magnitude of the signal and background noise. Many amplifier manufacturers publish their SNR figures at full power, which can be misleading and hard to compare between different amplifiers at differently rated power levels. Many also apply weighing filters to yield better results such as dBa or dBc. This can make over a 10dB difference compared to unweighted measurements and should be noted when comparing various amplifiers. It is best to look at 1 watt levels (where the amp spends most of its time) and interpolate the SNR at the amplifiers full rated power. We will leave this topic for another article in the near future.

Frequency Response - This is a measure of how well an amplifier will reproduce a signal without attenuation or boosting with ideal being flat within the range of human hearing 20Hz to 20kHz +/- 0dB. This again is rarely a problem with well designed amps and there should be little reason why an amplifier cannot maintain at least +-.5dB from 20Hz to 20kHz. Some amps do result in excessive power fall off at high frequency due to slew rate induced distortion and this is something to watch out for. Thus why we check frequency response at 1 watt and full power for our amplifier testing.

Amplifier Output Impedance - This again is an important metric as it determines the amount of interaction or frequency response variation an amplifier may produce when driven by a reactive loudspeaker load. Usually lower is better, but some do prefer high output impedance tube amps for example since they can excessively roll off high frequency response and result in a warm sound. Note, sonically preferring something doesn't necessarily mean its more accurate or precise.

Damping Factor - This specification is somewhat overstated by most manufacturers and the reader is encouraged to reference our article: Damping Factor - Effects on System Response for more information. I still like to check for this as it is a good indication of amplifier output impedance and power supply capability. However, in real world scenarios, cable impedance usually nullifies the benefits of a very high damping factor and thus beyond a certain value as stipulated in the aforementioned article it becomes mostly academic.

Amplifier Measurement Techniques

Required Test Equipment

  • Non inductive Resistors (8 ohms, 4 ohms)
  • Oscilloscope
  • Short 10AWG Speaker Cables
  • Function Generator

Measuring Output Impedance and Power of Amplifiers

clip_image002_034

Step 1: Adjust the function generator until you read 2.82Vrms on the Unloaded amplifier as depicted in the left figure above. Record these results in Table 1. under 'Vopen' over the entire frequency range.

Step 2: Attach a non inductive Load to the amplifier and re-measure the output voltage over frequency and record the data in the appropriate 舠 Vload 舡 column specific to the load impedance used in this test in the three Tables below. Do NOT vary amplitude of the function generator, only Frequency.

Step 3: Calculate the amplifier output impedance (Zo) with the following relationship.

VLoad = (RL / RL+Zo)*Vopen

Solve for Zo = > Zo = RL*Vopen/VLoad - RL

and

System Damping Factor = (RL+Rcable) / Zo

Step 4 : Plot the data from the Tables into Figures in excel.

Step 5 : Find the maximum unclipped voltage the amplifier can provide into the specified test load.

Step 6: Record the voltage over the specified frequency range.

Step 7: Detach the test load and record the voltage 'Vopen' vs frequency repeating step 3 to calculate output impedance.

Note: The following variables limit the absolute accuracy of this test method:

  • Cable impedance and stray inductance in resistor
  • Variance in line voltage (since all tests are done without a line stabilizer)

However, this is more of a real world than typical ideal test condition, thus for all intents and purposes serves well for this application.

Test Notes:

  • The 8ohm test load + test cable measured: Rdc = 8.04 ohms ; Ls = 5uH (1kHz)
  • The 4 ohm test load + test cable measured: Rdc = 4.03 ohms ; Ls = 3.8uH (1kHz)
  • All measurements were done in 'Pure Direct Mode'
  • Line Voltage was NOT held constant and varied between 117-119VAC
  • All tests were conducted on the main channels of the RX-V2500
  • All tests were conducted using EXT Multi-CH Inputs and Outputs when appropriate

Measurements and Analysis for Yamaha RX-V2500 A/V Receiver

Line Level, 8-ohm Load (RL=10kohm)

Frequency

Vopen

VLoad

Zo

Freq Resp

Damping Factor

Vout

Freq Resp

20

2.81

2.77

0.116

-0.09

69

0.99

-0.09

100

2.8

2.79

0.029

-0.03

279

0.99

-0.09

250

2.81

2.8

0.029

0.00

280

0.99

-0.09

500

2.82

2.8

0.057

0.00

140

0.99

-0.09

1000

2.83

2.8

0.086

0.00

93

0.99

-0.09

2500

2.82

2.79

0.086

-0.03

93

0.99

-0.09

5000

2.81

2.8

0.029

0.00

280

1

0.00

10000

2.82

2.79

0.086

-0.03

93

1

0.00

16000

2.82

2.77

0.145

-0.09

55

0.99

-0.09

20000

2.79

2.76

0.091

-0.14

88

0.99

-0.10

Table 1. 1 Watt Amplifier Tests & Line Level Measurements

Full Power, 8-ohm Load



8ohm; 1CH

8ohm; 2CH

1CH 2CH


Frequency

Vopen

VLoad

Vload

Zo

Power

Power

Damping Factor

20

34.5

34.4

33

0.023

147

135

344

100

34.5

34.2

32.6

0.071

145

132

114

250

34.8

34.4

32.8

0.093

147

134

86

500

34.8

34.4

32.9

0.093

147

135

86

1000

34.6

34.5

33

0.023

148

135

345

2500

34.7

34.4

33.1

0.070

147

136

115

5000

34.7

34.2

33

0.118

145

135

68.4

10000

34.5

34.3

33.1

0.047

146

136

172

16000

34.4

34.2

33

0.047

145

135

171

20000

33.8

33.3

32.2

0.126

143

134

64

Table 2. Full Unclipped Power Amplifier Tests for 8 ohm load

Full Power, 4-ohm Load






4ohm; 1CH
4ohm; 2CH

Frequency

Vopen

VLoad

Vload

Zo

Power

Power

Damping Factor

20

34.5

28.3

21.9

0.883

199

119

5

100

34.5

28.4

22

0.866

200

120

4.7

250

34.8

28.5

22

0.891

202

120

4.5

500

34.8

28.5

22

0.891

202

120

4.5

1000

34.6

28.3

22

0.897

199

120

4

2500

34.7

28.3

21.9

0.911

199

119

4

5000

34.7

28.4

21.8

0.894

200

118

4.51

10000

34.5

28.1

22

0.918

196

120

4

16000

34.4

28.1

21.6

0.904

196

116

4

20000

33.8

28.0

21.1

0.839

196

115

5

Table 3. Full Unclipped Power Amplifier Tests for 4ohm load