Skip to content. Skip to navigation
You are here: Home Pro Reviews Projectors Panasonic PT-AX200U LCD Projector Review PT-AX200U Calibration and Benchmark Tests
 

PT-AX200U Calibration and Benchmark Tests

by Clint DeBoer last modified November 05, 2007

PT-AX200U-CIE-colors.jpgLike the PT-AX100U, the PT-AX200U handles reds and blues to the maximum limits of NTSC color. Greens tend to be a bit desaturated – though towards blue rather than yellow. Here are the Contrast Ratios I measured in the various Picture modes:

  • Game (default) – 1623:1
  • Cinema1 – 661:1
  • Normal – 1746:1
  • Dynamic – 2074:1

I also took a brief survey of the various color temperatures and confirmed that with a simple setting you could get very good ISF-type levels from this projector out of the box without too much hassle:

  • Cinema1 – 7000K
  • Normal – 8800K
  • Game – 9000K
  • Natural – 7700K
  • Cinema2 – 7600K
  • Dynamic – 7900K
  • Vivid Cinema – 6550K

The first thing I did upon seeing the slightly increased temperature for the default Cinema1 mode, is attempt to bump down the Color Temp slider by -1 to see what would happen. The result was almost exactly 6500K. Now, be advised, some people just don't like 6500K whites. You may prefer a slightly less red white level at the default 7000K and who am I to argue with the settings put in place by Hollywood colorists? In any case, realize that bumping this setting is what yielded the results below.

Measurements

We utilized datacolor’s ColorFacts Professional 6.0 software to calibrate and measure the grayscale response of the PT-AX200U. Panasonic is again making sure that users have some very helpful default settings “out of the box”. We measured the Cinema1 mode and received the following excellent results:

RGB Levels

Color Temperature

PT-AX200U-RGB-levels.jpg

PT-AX200U-temperature.jpg

You’re looking at the Cinema1 mode with no calibration. Red and blue only lead green slightly from 40 IRE onward. That bump at 30 could be smoothed out, but overall I felt no pressing need to calibrate this projector beyond the defaults.

Color is all but pinned at 6500K from 40-80 IRE, dropping only slightly thereafter. The dips at 30 and below didn't really bother me too much and I was quite impressed with how well this projector fared overall.

These are very close to exactly what I expect to see “pre-calibration”. Often I find that the variance in color response is much more erratic and rarely do we find projectors at this price which don't really demand calibration to deliver a great picture.

Audioholics/HQV Bench Testing Summary of Test Results

Perfect Score is 130
Panasonic PT-AX200U Benchmark Score: 90
(identical to the PT-AX100U as expected)

Test Max
Points
Component
Results
Component
Pass/Fail
Color Bar 10 10 Pass
Jaggies #1 5 5 Pass
Jaggies #2 5 5 Pass
Flag 10 5 Pass
Detail 10 10 Pass
Noise 10 5 Pass
Motion adaptive Noise Reduction 10 0 Fail
Film Detail 10 10 Pass
Cadence 2:2 Video 5 5 Pass
Cadence 2:2:2:4 DV Cam 5 5 Pass
Cadence 2:3:3:2 DV Cam 5 0 Fail
Cadence 3:2:3:2:2 Vari-speed 5 0 Fail
Cadence 5:5 Animation 5 0 Fail
Cadence 6:4 Animation 5 5 Pass
Cadence 8:7 animation 5 0 Fail
Cadence 3:2 24fps film 5 5 Pass
Scrolling Horizontal 10 10 Pass
Scrolling Rolling 10 10 Pass
Total Points 130 90

Comments on Benchtesting

There were no surprises here. We ran the HQV suite of tests and found identical results to the PT-AX100U. A score of 90 shows that the Panasonic has an adequate video processor for the most important processing duties. The fact that it marginally passed the flag test, however, shows that it may be a tad favorable towards the tests and not tweaked as well for real-world content.

When running the Moving Zone Plate tests, 2/3 passed while 2/2 and the Default failed. There was plenty of flickering at higher speeds, but I detected no breakup of the image in any direction.

 

Recent Forum Posts:

Post Reply
TVJon posts on December 13, 2007 23:12
I have this PJ running in my almost-done media room. I like it a lot and have no issues with the machine. What I find most interesting (this is my first PJ) is how soft and low-resolution some of my old standard definition DVDs look on the "big screen." I suppose that's what you get when you're actually looking what amounts to seven pixels per inch on a screen that's 8-feet across.. assuming 640 pixels horizontal resolution. The other thing watching on the big screen does is make me follow the rack focuses and notice soft camera shots more than I ever did on television.

The price you pay for watching DVDs REALLY big... and why I want to see the difference HD really makes.

TVJon
RTPBob posts on November 29, 2007 17:05
Does anyone know which level of HDMI the AX200U supports? I've been reading about the advantages of 1.3 but haven't been able to track down what level this projector supports.

Thanks,
Bob
Allan Rast posts on November 10, 2007 21:12
majorloser;327349
So I take it you don't have any HDCP issues with the Dish-HD HDMI signal? If not, this might end up becoming my "spare" projector.



I "found" the review of this projector and followed the links to this forum. I am thinking of getting this projector to replace a 1995 vintage Sharp LCD projector. I also wonder about others having the HDCP issues.

I'm thinking of also getting the Denon 3808CI receiver. I bought one of the Toshiba HD-A2 HD DVD players at Wal-Mart the day of the big sale.

Does this sound like a reasonable system to everyone? Thanks in advance for responses.
majorloser posts on November 07, 2007 14:36
TOADSKI;326635
I bought this for my new dedicated theater, Dish HD is amazing I dont have a a HD DVD but but christmas is coming. i can watch this with lights on if needed.
the cons to me are the 120 ft power cord supplied with the machine I need a 1 ft cord. For once a company gives a really long cord and I dont need it.
It worked great right out of the box.


So I take it you don't have any HDCP issues with the Dish-HD HDMI signal? If not, this might end up becoming my "spare" projector.
Clint DeBoer posts on November 07, 2007 08:24
I'd be interested to hear from even more people who own this projector and see what they think or if they encountered any difficulties.
Post Reply
 
Join our Newsletter for News & Deals